Skip to main content
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); paint decoration by Ann Butler, (1813–1887), Trunk, Greenvill…
Trunk
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); paint decoration by Ann Butler, (1813–1887), Trunk, Greenvill…
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); paint decoration by Ann Butler, (1813–1887), Trunk, Greenville, New York, c. 1830, Paint on asphaltum over tinplate, 4 1/8 × 6 3/4 × 3 3/4", Collection American Folk Art Museum, New York, Gift of the Historical Society of Early American Decoration, courtesy Esther Oldham and Anne Oldham Borntraeger, 53.2.2. Photo by John Parnell
Record Details

Trunk

Artist ((act. 1824–c. 1855))
Date1824 –1859
Place/RegionGreenville, New York, United States
MediumPaint and asphaltum on tinplate
Dimensions4 1/8 × 6 3/4 × 3 3/4"
Credit LineGift of the Historical Society of Early American Decoration, courtesy Esther Oldham and Anne Oldham Borntraeger
Accession number53.2.2
CopyrightThe American Folk Art Museum believes this work to be in the public domain.
Description

This piece is signed and initialed by Ann Butler, eldest daughter of Aaron Butler (1790–1860) who came to Greene County, New York, from Connecticut in 1799 and established a general store, hay press, cider mill, and brandy business. His home on Brandy Hill also became the site of his tin shop, which opened in 1824 and continued to operate until a few years before his death. The tin shop employed as many as forty workers, including most members of his own family.

Butler's sons were occupied with the manufacture and distribution of the tinwares, and several of his daughters painted the floral decorations. Ann took over decorating by the age of fourteen or fifteen and probably taught her sisters how to paint. She married about 1840 and moved with her husband, Eli Scutt, to Livingstonville, New York. Her work is characterized by dense decoration with a variety of tulips, rosebuds, and diamond baskets, with multiple filler elements.

Stacy C. Hollander, "Trunk," in American Anthem: Masterworks from the American Folk Art Museum (New York: Harry N. Abrams in association with American Folk Art Museum, 2001), 319.
 
Object information is a work in progress and may be updated with new research. Records are reviewed and revised, and the American Folk Art Museum welcomes additional information. 

To help improve this record, please email photoservices@folkartmuseum.org 

Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); paint decoration by Ann Butler, (1813–1887), Tea Caddy, Green…
Butler Shop
1824–1859
53.2.4
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); paint decoration by Ann Butler, (1813–1887), Trinket Box, Gre…
Butler Shop
c. 1830
53.2.5
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855); Ann Butler, (1813–1887), “Chippendale-style Tea Caddy,” Green…
Butler Shop
c. 1830
53.2.3
Butler Shop, (act. 1824–c. 1855), “Bread Tray,” Greenville, New York, United States, c. 1830, P…
Butler Shop
c. 1830
64.8
Stevens Shop, (act. 1798–1842), “Bun Basket”, Stevens Plains (now Westbrook), Maine, United Sta…
Stevens Shop
c. 1815-1835
58.13.22
North Shop, (act. c. 1790–1841); paint decoration attributed to Mercy North, (1798–1872), “Trun…
North Shop
1798–1838
76.10
Boynton Shop, (act. 1812–1877), “Apple Basket,” New Hampshire or Massachusetts, United States, …
Boynton Shop
c. 1815–1835
75.1.4
Artist unidentified, “Pap Warmer”, England, Second half of the 19th century, Paint on tinplate,…
Artist unidentified
Second half of the 19th century
59.1.23
Artist unidentified
c. 1815–1835
76.4.2
Artist unidentified, “Crooked Spout Coffeepot,” Possibly New York, c. 1815—1835, Paint on aspha…
Artist unidentified
c. 1815—1835
70.3.6
Artist unidentified, “Mug,” Eastern United States, c. 1815—1835, Paint on asphaltum over tinpla…
Artist unidentified
c. 1815—1835
70.4.16
Artist unidentified, “Tumbler,” Eastern United States, c. 1815—1835, Paint on asphaltum over ti…
Artist unidentified
c. 1815—1835
70.4.3